President Donald Trump and Secretary of State Marco Rubio at the White House, Oct. 20, 2025. Photo: Daniel Torok / Official White House Photo via Flickr / United States Government Work

(The Center Square) — The U.S. carried out a "large scale strike against Venezuela" in the overnight hours Saturday, capturing Venezuelan President Nicolas Maduro, along with his wife, according to a social media post from President Donald Trump.

The president said Maduro and his wife have been flown out of the country, but didn't indicate where they have been taken. He added that the operation was "done in conjunction with U.S. Law Enforcement."

Secretary of State has said in the past that "Maduro is NOT the President of Venezuela and his regime is NOT the legitimate government."

In a social media post on X from July, Rubio called Maduro the head of the "Cartel de Los Soles, a narco-terror organization" that took "possession of the country. And he is under indictment for pushing drugs into the United States."

Trump said a news conference will be held later Saturday morning.

This is a developing story.

'Large scale strike' carried out against Venezuela; Maduro captured

(The Center Square) — The U.S. carried out a "large scale strike against Venezuela" in the overnight hours Saturday, capturing Ve...
A protestor speaking in a small group in support of Trump carries gun on her belt during the Women's March Phoenix Rally outside of the Arizona State Capitol on January 19, 2020. - Nicole Neri/The Republic/Imagn

A US appeals court ruled on Friday that California's ban on openly carrying firearms in most parts of the state was unconstitutional.

A panel of the San Francisco-based 9th US Circuit Court of Appealssided, opens new tab2-1 with a gun owner in ruling that the state's prohibition against open carry in counties with more than 200,000 people violated the US Constitution's Second Amendment right to keep and bear arms.

About 95% of the population in California, which has had some of the nation's strictest gun-control laws, live in counties of that size.

US Circuit Judge Lawrence VanDyke, who was appointed by Republican President Donald Trump, said the Democratic-led state's law could not stand under the US Supreme Court's 2022landmark gun rights ruling.

That decision, New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v Bruen, was issued by the court's 6-3 conservative super majority and established a new legal test for firearms restrictions. The test said they must be "consistent with this nation's historical tradition of firearm regulation."

VanDyke, whose opinion on Friday was joined by another Trump appointee, said the latest case "unquestionably involves a historical practice — open carry — that predates ratification of the Bill of Rights in 1791."

He noted that more than 30 states generally allow open carry. California itself allowed citizens to carry handguns openly and holstered for self-defense without penalty until 2012, he said.

"The historical record makes unmistakably plain that open carry is part of this Nation's history and tradition," VanDyke said.

The ruling partially reversed a 2023 decision by a lower-court judge who had rejected a 2019 challenge to the law by gun owner Mark Baird.

While the appeals court largely sided with Baird, it rejected his related challenge to California's licensing requirements in counties with fewer than 200,000 residents, which may issue open-carry permits.

Senior US Circuit Judge N. Randy Smith, who was appointed by Republican former President George W. Bush, dissented, saying his colleagues "got this case half right" as all of California's restrictions complied with the Supreme Court's ruling.

A spokesperson for California Attorney General Rob Bonta, a Democrat who defended the state's ban, in a statement said his office is considering its options. "We are committed to defending California's common sense gun laws," the spokesperson said.

The 2022 Supreme Court ruling has prompted court cases nationwide challenging modern firearm restrictions, including in California.

A 9th Circuit panel in September 2024 upheld a California law that prohibits people with concealed-carry permits from carrying firearms at several categories of "sensitive places" like bars, parks, zoos, stadiums and museums.

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account atCNN.com

California ban on openly carrying guns is unconstitutional, court rules

A US appeals court ruled on Friday that California's ban on openly carrying firearms in most parts of the state was unconstitutional. ...
Trial to begin for police officer charged in delayed response to Uvalde school shooting

Families who lost loved ones in the 2022 attack onan elementary schoolin Uvalde, Texas, have sought for nearly four yearsto hold accountablethe police who waited more than an hour to confront the shooter while children and teachers lay dead or wounded in classrooms.

Now one of the first officers on the scene is about tostand trialon multiple charges of child abandonment and endangerment. Former Uvalde schools police officer Adrian Gonzales is accused of ignoring his training in a crisis with deadly consequences. His attorney insists he was focused on helping children escape from the building.

The trial that starts Monday offers potentially one of the last chances to see police answer for the long delay. The families have pinned their hopes on the jury after their gun-control efforts were rejected by lawmakers, and their lawsuits remain unresolved. A few parents ran for political office to seek change, with mixed results.

The proceedings will provide a rare example of an officer being criminally charged with not doing more to stop a crime and protect lives.

Jesse Rizo's niece was one of 19 children and two teachers killed by the teenage gunman in one of the deadliest school shootings in U.S. history. Nine-year-old Jackie Cazares still had a pulse when rescuers finally reached her, Rizo said.

"It really bothers us a lot that maybe she could have lived," he said.

Only two of the 376 officersfrom local, state and federal agencies on the scene have been charged — a fact that haunts Velma Lisa Duran, whose sister, Irma Garcia, was one of the teachers gunned down.

"What about the other 374?" Duran asked through tears. "They all waited and allowed children and teachers to die."

The charges reflect the dead and wounded children, but not her sister's death or that of the other teacher who was killed.

"Where is the justice in that?" Duran asked. "Did she not exist?"

Prosecutors will likely face a high bar to win a conviction. Juries are often reluctant to convict law enforcement officers for inaction, as seen after theParkland, Florida, school massacre in 2018.

Sheriff's deputy Scot Peterson was charged with failing to confront the shooter in that attack. It was the first such prosecution in the U.S. for an on-campus shooting, and Peterson wasacquittedby a jury in 2023.

The attack, the delay and the indictments

Police and Texas Gov. Greg Abbott initially said swift law enforcement action killed Uvalde gunman Salvador Ramos and saved lives. But that version quickly unraveled as families describedbegging police to go into the buildingand 911 calls emerged from students pleading for help.

The reality was that 77 minutes passed from the time officers first arrived until a tactical team breached the classroom and killed Ramos.

Multiple reportsfrom state and federal officials cataloged cascading problems in law enforcement training, communication, leadership and technology, and they questioned whether officers prioritized their own lives over those of the children and teachers.

Gonzales was charged two years later in an indictment that alleged he placed children in "imminent danger" of injury or death by failing to engage, distract or delay the gunman and by not following his active shooter training.

The indictment said he did not advance toward the gunfire despite hearing shots and being told where the shooter was.

The only other officer to be charged is formerUvalde schools Police Chief Pete Arredondo. His trial on similar charges has not yet been set.

Uvalde County District Attorney Christina Mitchell did not respond to requests from The Associated Press for comment on the indictments or whether a grand jury considered charging other officers.

According to a report by state lawmakers, Gonzales was among the first officers in the building. They heard gunfire and retreated without firing a shot after Ramos shot at them.

Gonzales told investigators he later helped break windows to remove students from other classrooms.

"He was focused on getting children out of that building," said Gonzales' attorney, Nico LaHood, a former district attorney and prosecutor in San Antonio. "He knows where his heart was and what he tried to do for those children."

The trial was moved from Uvalde to Corpus Christi, 200 miles away, after defense attorneys and prosecutors agreed a change of venue would be the best way to find an impartial jury.

A divided community

In Uvalde, a city of about 15,000 people, the Robb Elementary building is still standing, but it's empty. A memorial of 21 white crosses and flowers sits in front of the school sign. Another memorial is displayed at a downtown water fountain plaza. Murals of the victims cover walls on buildings around town.

Craig Garnett, owner and publisher of theUvalde Leader-Newsnewspaper, said people who were not directly affected by the attack "have found it pretty easy to move forward."

Garnett also believes getting the trial out of Uvalde was a good move for the city.

"The community was terribly divided in the aftermath," he said. If the trial were held there, "you would have so many opportunities to inflame things."

Some victims' parents sought political office but with little success.

Javier Cazares, Jackie's father, ran unsuccessfully in 2022 for the Uvalde County Commission as a write-in candidate on a platform that called for more rigorous police training. Kimberly Mata-Rubio, whose daughter Lexi was killed, made a bid for mayor in her memory in 2023 but lost.

Rizo, who won a seat on the school board in 2024, agreed that many Uvalde residents have moved on from May 24, 2022. He finds that maddening.

"I hear, 'They tried the best they could' and 'Do you blame them? Would you have taken a bullet?'" Rizo said. "It angers me and frustrates me."

Uvalde has a strong tradition of supporting law enforcement. Two of the people killed came from law enforcement families.

Mata-Rubio's husband was a sheriff's deputy who went to the school after the attack started. The other teacher killed, Eva Mireles, was married to one of the first officers to enter the building.

Families pursued multiple paths for justice

The families have sought justice through multiple legal paths.Federaland state lawsuits have been filedagainst law enforcement, a gun manufacturer, avideo gamecompany and theMeta social media companyover the shooting. Those cases are still pending.

The families reached a $2 million settlement with the city that promised higher standards and better training for police.

Relatives also lobbied state and federal lawmakers for stricter gun control laws that never advanced. But earlier this year, Texas lawmakers passed the Uvalde Strong Act, which sets new requirements for active shooter training and shooting response plans for police and schools.

Duran wants accountability not just for her sister but also for a beloved brother-in-law who died two days after the shooting.

Irma's husband, Joe, was watching a television report on the shooting when he heard that authorities missed their chance to end the attack quickly. He immediately fell to the floorwith an apparent heart attack, Duran said.

The conviction of a single officer out of almost 400 would bring little in the way of justice, Duran said.

"The only justice is going to be when they take their final breath," she said. "And then God will judge them."

Trial to begin for police officer charged in delayed response to Uvalde school shooting

Families who lost loved ones in the 2022 attack onan elementary schoolin Uvalde, Texas, have sought for nearly four years...
Florida iconic citrus groves are fighting for their lives

BARTOW, Florida – Citrus was a cornerstone of Florida's economy and identity for more than a century, but a decades-long decline driven by an invasive predator and relentless hurricanes leaves some wondering if the industry can ever recover.

Citrus once was "a behemoth" in the state, with nearly a million acres of trees, said Matt Joyner, executive vice president and CEO of Florida Citrus Mutual, the state's largest citrus trade association. Today it grows on fewer than 200,000 acres.

Production has plummeted nearly 92% since the season before a trio of hurricanes made landfall here in 2004. In winter 2024-2025, production reached thelowest point in morethan a century.

Ray ruby grapefruit hang on a tree inside a protective screen cover in Alturas, Florida to keep the pests that cause citrus greening away from the trees. Fresh Florida citrus displayed inside the market at Golden Ridge Groves in Bartow, in Polk County, Florida. Katie and Shane Bevilacqua stand in a grove under one of the protective screen covers that allow citrus frees and grapefruit to thrive while keeping the insect that causes citrus greening away. Shane Bevilacqua, co-owner of Golden Ridge Groves with his wife Katie, looks at the Ray ruby grapefruit growing in a grove under protective cover on his father-in-law's farm in Bartow, Florida. The Asian citrus psyllid likes to attack the tender, new growth on citrus trees like these fresh leaves. From there the bacteria it spreads spreads throughout the tree's vascular system. Shane Bevilacqua points to a graft on a citrus tree, which illustrates the efforts scientists and growers have undertaken to produce stronger, more resistant trees and improved fruit. Jude Grosser, a professor of plant cell genetics at the University of Florida's Citrus Research and Education Center in Lake Alfred, Florida, holds a few of a newer variety of citrus being grown under a protective cover at Mixon KLM farms. Working with owner Jerry Mixon and his family, Grosser keeps an eye on the success of programs to improve trees and fruit. Ray ruby grapefruit hang on a tree inside a protective screen cover near Bartow, Florida to keep the pests that cause citrus greening away from the trees. The structures have proven very beneficial for the fruit and the trees. Ray ruby grapefruit hang on a tree inside a protective screen cover near Bartow, Florida to keep the pests that cause citrus greening away from the trees. Recently harvested Ray ruby grapefruit have been rinsed and are waiting at Golden Ridge Groves to be boxed up. Ray ruby grapefruit, a red and sweet variety, is displayed at Golden Ridge Groves in Bartow, Florida. A worker picking citrus in Polk County, Florida in 1946, from the Florida Photographic Collection . Theodore Strawn's packing house for Bob White oranges in DeLeon Springs, Florida, circa 1910 from the Florida Photographic Collection. A label for the Grown in Old Volusia brand from Theodore Strawn, Inc. of De Leon Springs, Florida, circa 1930.

Florida citrus industry works to rebound from citrus greening

In early 2025, the state's largest commercial grower announced it would end its citrus operations in Florida,citing economic conditions.

However, many growers and scientists aren't ready to close the book on Florida's citrus history.

They are fighting back against the voracious Asian citrus psyllid and the tree-killing bacterial disease known as "citrus greening" it carries.

Through breeding and genetics, researchers and growers have developed trees "showing tremendous resistance, if not tolerance, to greening," Joyner said.

Invasive species has been attacking Florida citrus groves

Florida growers have seen troubles before, including pests and disease such as canker, which still lingers, and historic tree-killing freezes, but psyllid is considered the gravest threat to citrus trees and fruit worldwide.

The particularly devastating strain of the disease it spreads – Huanglongbing (HLB), or Candidatus Liberibacter asiaticus – has affected dozens of countries. It's found in several states, but Florida has been hardest hit.

The bugs, barely an eighth of an inch long, arrived in the state in 1998, and were detected in the commercial citrus industry in 2005. Since then,they've wreaked havoc.

"We have had a 90% reduction in acreage and production compared with pre HLB," said Ute Albrecht, anassociate professor of plant physiologywith the University of Florida's Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences.

Katie and Shane Bevilacqua stand in a grove under one of the protective screen covers that allow citrus frees and grapefruit to thrive while keeping the insect that causes citrus greening away.

During the 2024-25 season, growers produced 14.6 million boxes, down more than 25% from the previous year. It had been 125 years since production was that low. At its height, the industry produced 304 million boxes a season.

The scientists blame the extent of the virus in part on Florida's heat and rain,which encourages the new growth the insects prefer to eat, hurricanes that move the bugs into new areas and delays in efforts to eradicate the psyllids from the moment they first appeared in South Florida.

Psyllids operate like malaria-carrying mosquitoes, taking the disease from infected trees to healthy ones. When the virus hits a tree, it spreads "everywhere, not just in the leaves or on the surface," Albrecht said.

Growers are working with scientists to develop and use promising treatments and tools to beat back the bugs and bacteria. That includes working with hundreds of varieties of trees and fruit to develop trees with hardier root systems and tree tops.

They're also three years intoapplying a treatmentthat Albrecht helped develop to curb the bacterial infection. They're expanding the acres grown under protective screen structures that keep out the psyllids. Other advances include helping trees produce a protein that can kill tiny, young psyllids.

State and federal programs also are assisting with the cost of new tree plantings and development of the newer tools to treat the disease.

Things are "moving in the right direction," Joyner said. "It's kind of exciting to see some resurgence."

'A guiding light'

The figures showing the industry's decline miss the optimism and determination of growers and scientists working to turn things around, Joyner said.

"It's easy to look at just the stats and charts and get a wrong view of what's going on in Florida citrus," he said.

Shane and Katie Bevilacqua, co-owners of Golden Ridge Groves near Bartow aren't ready to give up. Neither is Steve Crump, whose family has grown fruit in DeLeon Springs for more than 130 years.

As these growers collaborate with scientists to find solutions, they are excited aboutadvances that include new varieties of root stockand trees that are more resilient, tolerant, grow faster and produce more desirable fruit.

The greening devastation pushed researchers to accelerate genetic research,said Jude Grosser,a professor of plant cell geneticsat UF's Citrus Research and Education Center in Lake Alfred.

Jude Grosser, a professor of plant cell genetics at the University of Florida's Citrus Research and Education Center in Lake Alfred, Florida, holds a few of a newer variety of citrus being grown under a protective cover at Mixon KLM farms. Working with owner Jerry Mixon and his family, Grosser keeps an eye on the success of programs to improve trees and fruit.

These days Grosser spends much of his time in the field, walking through groves searching for the best trees and fruit. He and colleagues are working to find and isolate the "right" traits among thousands of hybrids planted in the groves and cross them with others to improve both trees and fruit.

The University of Florida team has been "a guiding light," said Shane Bevilacqua, co-owner ofGolden Ridge Groveswith his wife. Katie's father, Jerry Mixon, grandfather and uncle have long partnered with the University and are known for being pioneers in thegrowth of Florida's blueberry industry."I come from a long line of risk takers and problem solvers," she said.

In 2016, Jerry Mixon began planting trees under a screened, protective structure designed to keep the bugs out. Now the farm has about 700 acres under protective cover.

The Bevilacquas opened Golden Ridge in November to tours, you-pick opportunities and tastings to share with the public what's going on inside the protective structures. It's a way to bring citrus science to the public, she said, and to get direct feedback from consumers on the newer varieties of fruit.

Growers have seen big collateral benefits to the screen structures, the Bevilacquas said. Protected from the wind and to some degree from the sun, trees grow far faster in the humid environment than those outside the screen. They also produce more and higher quality fruit.

"We're much more efficient with what we do on a per acre basis," Grosser said. "A whole host of things have come out of the research we've done on greening that has given us better practices."

Getting a head start

About 90 miles to the northeast of the research center in Polk County, Florida, Steve Crump's great-grandfather Chester Strawn planted orange trees in the late 1800s. The family has battled and come back before, after bitter freezes in 1894-95 and nearly a century later in 1989.

When he planted his first citrus trees under one of the protective screened structures four years ago, Grosser warned Crump the trees would grow fast.

"Compared to the stuff I'm growing outside, it's unbelievably fast," said Crump, executive director of Volusia County Farm Bureau. "The quality of the fruit is the best I've ever grown."

Encouraged by the growth, flavor and production he sees at the family'sVo-LaSalle Farms, and after much deliberation about the future, he is expanding the area under screen.

The enclosures cost tens of thousands per acre, and repair costs can pile up after storms like Hurricane Milton in 2024. Grosser said the expense means farmers growing under them will need to shift to producing more higher value varieties, rather than focusing on juice as they have in the past.

Farmers in Florida and Georgia also are using individual screen covers on new young trees planted outside. If they can keep the trees covered for a couple of years to give them a head start on building a healthy root system, it can give the trees an increased lifespan.

What to know about the Asian citrus psyllid

Homeowners can also canhelp curb the problemby monitoring their own citrus trees, learning to recognize the bugs and greening symptoms, and using insecticides and measures to keep their trees healthy.

The Asian citrus psyllid likes to attack the tender, new growth on citrus trees like these fresh leaves. From there the bacteria it spreads spreads throughout the tree's vascular system.

Among the symptoms to watch for, according to the U.S. Department of Agriculture, are the following:

  • Psyllid eggs are yellow-orange, almond-shaped and often tucked inside crevices and leaf folds.

  • The tiny nymphs leave waxy, white excretions on the leaves.

  • Even when a tree is asymptomatic, it can be a bacteria source to infect other trees.

  • Leaves may show blotches and mottled coloring and fruit may remain partially green and irregularly shaped.

Saving Florida's citrus fruit

Saving Florida's citrus will require a concerted and combined strategy, Albrecht said.

"You really have to use a whole arsenal of things, from nutrition, irrigation, pests, insecticides and injections," she said. "Ultimately the best way to solve this or to live with it, is really by having better varieties that can handle the disease."

The goal is to developa portfolio of root stocksthat farmers can use to choose the best options for their farms, based on their soil, salinity, insect and disease problems and the type of fruit they want to produce, Grosser said. With the advancements, progressive people who have capital and are willing to try different things, he said, are "going to make it."

Ray ruby grapefruit hang on a tree inside a protective screen cover in Alturas, Florida to keep the pests that cause citrus greening away from the trees.

The industry also hopes to develop fruit that could be mechanically harvested and stand up to packing and transport, Grosser said, as well as to improve varieties that will maintain their juice flavor and quality after pasteurization. In a juice-tasting at a December fundraiser, a new variety of orange, named for the late Orie Lee, a member of the Florida Citrus Hall of Fame, blended with mandarin orange juice, was the crowd's hands down favorite, he said.

Another obstacle to the full recovery of the citrus industry is the dwindling acreage available for new groves amidst the increasing demand for land for new subdivisions and homes. Farmers who gave up battling greening and let their trees die, are getting huge offers for their property, Grosser said. The land, if sold, will "never come back into agriculture."

Joyner and others hope these concerns can be addressed by a continued focus on state-sponsored farm preservation programs that reward farmers for conserving their land.

The industry's survival is crucial for green space and rural economies, Joyner said, and for consumers who want to continue buying domestically grown fresh fruit and juice.

A cluster of oranges in Florida is shown in a postcard from the Detroit Photographic Co., postmarked in 1907.

Dinah Voyles Pulver, a national correspondent for USA TODAY and Florida native, has covered the environment, weather and climate change for decades. Reach her at dpulver@usatoday.com or @dinahvp on Bluesky or X or dinahvp.77 on Signal.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY:Florida citrus in crisis as invasive predator spreads

Florida iconic citrus groves are fighting for their lives

BARTOW, Florida – Citrus was a cornerstone of Florida's economy and identity for more than a century, but a decades-l...
Photos show residents evacuating after explosions in Caracas, Venezuela

CARACAS, Venezuela (AP) — The United Stateshit Venezuela with a "large-scale strike"early Saturday and said its president, Nicolás Maduro, had been captured and flown out of the country aftermonths of stepped-up pressureby Washington.

People fled in panic as the explosions went off around them. The government has accused the U.S. of attacking civilian and military sites.

This is a photo gallery curated by AP photo editors.

Photos show residents evacuating after explosions in Caracas, Venezuela

CARACAS, Venezuela (AP) — The United Stateshit Venezuela with a "large-scale strike"early Saturday and said its...
NASA's MAVEN Orbiter Set For Mission to Mars (Bill Ingalls / NASA via Getty Images)

For nearly a month, NASA has been scrambling to make contact with a spacecraft in orbit aroundMarsthat abruptly fell silent.

The space agency lost communication with theMAVEN probe(short for Mars Atmosphere and Volatile EvolutioN) on Dec. 6, and efforts to re-establish a connection have been futile. Based on bits of data received that day, mission controllers think the probe was spinning unexpectedly.

NASA now has to wait until Jan. 16 before it can again try to revive MAVEN, because Mars and Earth have been on opposite sides of the sun since Monday, resulting in a prolonged communications blackout.

Overall, it's not looking promising for one of NASA's workhorse missions.

Since the MAVEN spacecraftentered orbit around Mars in 2014, it has been studying the red planet's upper atmosphere, including a plasma layer known as the ionosphere, and investigating how and why Mars has been losing its atmosphere over billions of years. The spacecraft has also been instrumental in relaying communications between two rovers on the surface of Mars, Curiosity and Perseverance, and Earth.

NASA hasn't been able to reach MAVEN since it experienced what the agency called a "loss of signal" with ground stations on Earth on Dec. 6. At the time, the spacecraft was orbiting behind Mars, so the signal loss was routine and expected, as Mars always blocks MAVEN from phoning home during the maneuver. This time, however, when the probe re-emerged from behind the red planet, NASA could not pick up any signals from it.

NASA said it was "investigating the anomaly" in astatement on Dec. 9but provided few details. Mission controllers reported that all of MAVEN's subsystems had been working normally before it passed behind Mars.

In an update about a week later, NASA said no transmissions had been received from MAVEN since Dec. 4, but that engineers had recovered a brief fragment of tracking data from Dec. 6.

What they found was troubling: "Analysis of that signal suggests that the MAVEN spacecraft was rotating in an unexpected manner when it emerged from behind Mars," NASA officialssaid in a statement.

The space agency has been using a global array of giant radio antennas, known as the Deep Space Network, to send commands to MAVEN and monitor for any incoming signals. On Dec. 16 and 20, NASA tried snapping photos of MAVEN in orbit from the surface of Mars, using an instrument aboard the agency's Curiosity rover.

At the same time, mission controllers are closely analyzing the last fragments of tracking data recovered.NASA said on Dec. 23that it was attempting to piece together a timeline of events to figure out what went wrong. NASA did not provide additional details in a request for comment and referred NBC News to the agency's update on Dec. 23.

The MAVEN mission was originally designed to last just two years, but it has been operating continuously for more than a decade. In 2024, NASA celebrated the probe's 10th anniversary orbiting Mars.

By studying the process of atmospheric loss on Mars, MAVEN was helping scientists get a clearer picture of the planet's past and present climate and how ittransformed from a potentially habitable worldwith liquid water on its surface to the cold and barren planet that it is today.

The spacecraft is one of three that NASA currently has in orbit around Mars. The space agency also operates the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter, which launched in 2005, and Mars Odyssey, which lifted off in 2001.

A NASA spacecraft orbiting Mars may be dead

For nearly a month, NASA has been scrambling to make contact with a spacecraft in orbit aroundMarsthat abruptly fell silent. The space age...
'Somewhere to put worker bees': Why Canada's micro-condos are losing their appeal

Maggie Hildebrand's first apartment in Toronto had a kitchen, a dining table, a workspace and a bed – all in the same 300-sq-ft room.

It was a decent home at first, close enough to her job downtown and with all the bare necessities for daily living.

But it didn't take long for the 28-year-old to feel boxed-in. "It was so isolating in that tiny space," she told the BBC. "It definitely feels like it's just somewhere to put worker bees during the night."

Ms Hildebrand lived in one of the city's micro-condos, a once rare sight in Canadian real estate that has become ubiquitous in the last decade thanks to fast-growing, high-rise developments in major cities like Toronto and Vancouver.

But - as Canada's condominium market sinks to lows not seen in decades due to a series of market pressures - the value of these micro units is cratering faster than any others.

The condo market is experiencing a downturn not seen since the 1980s, with thousands of move-in-ready units sitting empty and unsold across Toronto and its surrounding regions. Over the last year, an unprecedented 18 condo projects were cancelled in the city, with experts expecting that number will grow as demand continues to plummet.

The downturn has reignited debate over whether developers catered too much to real estate investors by building smaller, more affordable units that minimised square footage to keep prices low in areas where land values are high, and which were often designed to be rented out or flipped for profit.

Investors own the majority of condos under 600 sq ft in Toronto, according to national database Statistics Canada. Construction of these small units skyrocketed in 2016, and they now make up 38% of condos built in the city, compared with only 7.7% before.

These units have not exploded in the same way in the US, where they represent a very small share of the market, though Nadia Evangelou, a senior economist at the National Association of Realtors, said "their prevalence has roughly doubled over the past decade".

With so much inventory on the market in Canada, some micro-condos that had sold for half a million dollars a few years ago are now reselling for C$300,000 ($217,000; £163,000) or less – a price recently unthinkable in downtown Toronto, which is often cited as one of the most unaffordable cities in the world.

"It's a race to the bottom getting these things sold," said Shaun Hildebrand, president of Urbanation, an organisation that has been tracking the high-rise market in Toronto for decades. (Shaun Hildebrand is not related to Ms Hildebrand.)

Why are so many condos sitting empty?

The condo slump is not unique to Toronto, with Vancouver experiencing a similar –albeit smaller – downturn since 2024.

There are a few reasons for this, experts tell the BBC.

First is an overabundant supply. Thousands of units were built over the last two years, in part to meet an unprecedented surge in Canada's population driven largely by immigration, Mr Hildebrand said.

But the number of newcomers dropped sharply following a shift in Canada's immigration policies, made partly to address the housing crunch. Areport released in December by the Bank of Montrealshows that Canada's population saw its largest decline in 2025 on record since the 1940s, barring the 2020 Covid pandemic, driven mainly by new immigration caps.

It is a turn-around that developers could not have predicted, and resulted in more than 60,000 new units completed in recent years to meet a demand that no longer exists.

Simply put, "the market just got way too ahead of itself", Mr Hildebrand said.

The second reason is pricing.

Canada's central bank lowered interest rates during the pandemic to stimulate the economy, and investors, looking to buy in a real estate market that had seemed like a sure bet for decades, assumed prices could only continue to rise.

For a while they did, spiking "to a level that really made no sense", Mr Hildebrand said.

Then, the Bank of Canada began to increase rates to battle post-pandemic inflation. Combined with oversupply, that sure bet became less certain.

Now, some investors are having trouble closing on units they bought pre-construction at those inflated prices. Many have been forced to try and sell them at a significant loss. Others are too spooked to enter the market or are waiting for prices to drop even further, Mr Hildebrand said.

There is some speculation thatCanada's 2022 freeze on foreign home buyers, brought in to help tackle the housing affordability crisis, also played a role. Numbers show that they represent a small fraction of owners – around 2% to 6% – but Mr Hildebrand said it is possible it has sent a signal that Canada is closed for business.

The condo crash and the housing market

One clear winner from the downturn of the condo market is renters like Ms Hildebrand, who now have more options due to greater supply and slightly better deals on rent.

Ms Hildebrand paid C$2,200 a month for her micro-condo. She has since moved to a larger, 700 square-foot, one-bedroom apartment in an older building with a leafy backyard for only C$200 more. She credits the move to a big improvement in her quality of life.

"My birthday is tomorrow, and I'm having a party and hosting 25 people," she told the BBC in December. "A year ago, that was not possible."

Mr Hildebrand said the slump will likely change who developers see as their main customer, shifting from short-term investors seeking quick profits towards longer-term investors and people who plan to settle in the condo they're buying,

"We've learned our lesson here," he said. The units won't be phased out altogether, he noted, because there is still demand for affordability, "but we went way too far".

Some buyers are benefiting, too. Alex Cruz, a Toronto-based estate agent at Ari Zadegan Group Realty, told the BBC that smaller units were being purchased by those looking for a bargain.

"If there is a good deal per square foot, people will buy it," Mr Cruz said, adding it had given some "an opportunity to get into the market".

The slump comes as Canada grapples with a housing crisis that has become a central political issue for all levels of government. Prime Minister Mark Carney has promised to double the rate of new homes built in the next decade.

With the construction of thousands of units now put on hold or cancelled, there will be fewer units entering the market by the end of the decade. This could exacerbate Canada's housing crunch, Mr Hildebrand said, as condos are heavily relied on to boost supply in big cities.

And Mr Hildebrand and others warn that the low prices will be short-lived.

"The question now is how long do we stay here, and what are the implications going to be for the housing supply in the next decade?" Mr Hildebrand said.

'Somewhere to put worker bees': Why Canada's micro-condos are losing their appeal

Maggie Hildebrand's first apartment in Toronto had a kitchen, a dining table, a workspace and a bed – all in the same...

 

VINCE JRNL © 2015 | Distributed By My Blogger Themes | Designed By Templateism.com